Talking Heads released Tentative Decisions in March, a 3-disc collection that charts the rapid evolution of the band’s original trio of David Byrne, Chris Frantz, and Tina Weymouth.
Building on an 11-song collection released last year for Record Store Day Black Friday, the new set adds 15 unreleased demos made for CBS in September 1975. As well as more than a dozen unreleased live recordings from the band’s first two years in New York.
The earliest recordings in the collection reach back to The Artistics, the band Frantz and Byrne formed while they were students at the Rhode Island School of Design. Recorded in 1974 at Frantz’s apartment on Benefit Street in Providence, the demo represents the earliest known recordings of “Psycho Killer” and “Warning Sign.”
In the liner notes, Frantz says the group’s original aspiration at that time was to become the RISD house band. Entertaining friends with covers of the Kinks, Motown and Al Green. But that all changed when the band started writing their own songs.
One day, Byrne knocked on the door of the painting studio Frantz and Weymouth shared and played them the first verse and chorus of “Psycho Killer,” which Frantz says “sounded promising.” Byrne asked Weymouth, who spoke French, to write lyrics for the bridge while Frantz added some verses, and so the band’s next chapter began.
After relocating from Rhode Island to New York City in early 1975, Talking Heads began recording early demos with their friend J.R. Rost to get an idea of what they sounded like. Those recordings open this collection.
That September, at the request of Mark Spector, they recorded an album’s worth of demos at CBS Studios.
While the session didn’t result in a contract, it did preserve early versions of songs that would form the backbone of the band’s first two albums. Including “Don’t Worry About The Government,” “The Book I Read,” “Thank You For Sending Me An Angel,” and “Stay Hungry.”
A cache of live recordings in the collection from 1976 and 1977 also captures the band at key moments. Including an October 1976 performance at Max’s Kansas City that took place just a few weeks before the group met with Seymour Stein and signed to Sire Records. As well as a January 1977 show at The Jabberwocky Club in Syracuse would be among the last by the original trio before Jerry Harrison joined in March.
At AllMusic, critic Fred Thomas remarks on the set that Byrne, Frantz and Weymouth were onto something even in their band’s earliest incarnations. Approaching music with the same openness to exploration and possibility they had as art school students.
With the raw fidelity of these recordings and performances that are sometimes more muted than their studio counterparts, Thomas says, it’s fascinating to hear how green the Talking Heads were when they were first starting out. And yet how strong their ideas already were.
Or as the graphic designer-esque all-type, long-copy cover art for “Tentative Decisions” says, “this collection traces the band’s progression from raw punk minimalism to a more structured, angular musical approach the reflects broader shifts in post-punk aesthetics of the late 1970s.”